Labor Day was profoundly significant when I delved into the service industry. Prior to this, my career path had led me through various roles, including serving as an EMT and a bridal consultant. The physical and emotional rollercoaster, peculiar injuries, and the experience of savoring cold yet surprisingly delicious fries as a bartender instilled in me an appreciation for Labor Day. Unlike other holidays that are marked by an energetic vibe, Labor Day is often regarded as just another day off. However, its significance is far more profound for those who have toiled in the service industry. Labor Day, dedicated to honoring workers' contributions, is particularly poignant for bartenders and servers who often work long hours, deal with challenging customers, and rely heavily on tips for their income.
In recent years, I have observed an uptick in the quick tip options offered by bars and restaurants' point of sales systems, with percentages reaching as high as 20%, 25%, and even 30%. This surge in gratuity has provoked ire in many, who find it audacious for service workers to solicit such hefty tips. However, as we find ourselves in 2024 grappling with soaring living costs and the elusive dream of homeownership, it is imperative to reflect on the unwavering dedication and hard work exhibited by bartenders and servers. These individuals often go above and beyond to ensure a pleasant experience for their patrons, and their efforts should be appreciated on this Labor Day.
Despite playing a pivotal role in our social lives, many service workers struggle with financial instability from meager base wages and erratic tipping practices. On this Labor Day, I am compelled to pose a critical and potentially contentious question: Should a 30% tipping standard be instituted as the new minimum in the service industry? The financial instability faced by bartenders is not just a concern for them, but a societal issue that needs urgent attention. This issue affects not only the individuals directly involved but also the communities they serve, making it a matter of collective responsibility.
The Economic Reality of Bartenders in 2024
Let's take a closer look at the economic landscape for bartenders in 2024. Bartending is a craft that demands a fusion of creativity, technical prowess, and adept interpersonal skills. Despite prevailing misconceptions, many bartenders are highly educated, resilient individuals. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the median hourly wage for bartenders in 2024, including tips, hovers around $12.50—an amount that scarcely covers basic living expenses in numerous regions. To secure health insurance, most bartenders are compelled to juggle two or even three jobs, with many still unable to afford it. This financial instability is a stark reality for many service workers, and it is time we address it.
For bartenders, tips are not merely a supplement to their income but an indispensable component. However, tipping norms have stagnated at 15-20% in most establishments. In an era of escalating living costs, this outdated tipping rate no longer sustains a livable wage for numerous service workers. While some may contend that raising the minimum wage to $15 or $20 would be excessive, considering the hurdles and financial instability confronting many service workers, a 30% tipping standard appears far from unreasonable.
The time has come to reassess our tipping customs and ensure that those toiling in the service industry receive equitable compensation for their unwavering commitment and hard work. What you see is that a bar patron or restaurant guest is a fraction of the energy and labor expended to do the job. Veterans like myself don't stay in a surface industry because it is always easy work, fun, or rewarding. Let's be honest: no job is. We stay because we love and are dedicated to what we do. Despite all this, bartenders' financial compensation often does not match the level of expertise they bring to their work. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the median hourly wage for bartenders in 2024, including tips, is approximately $12.50. This figure barely covers basic living expenses in many parts of the country, let alone allow for financial security or savings. Most bartenders will work a second and sometimes third job to be able to afford health insurance, but many will still go without and for cash pay clinics when available (roughly about $41k/yr). It's time for a change, a change that ensures fair and equitable compensation for all service workers. This change is not just a matter of policy but reflects our collective values and commitment to fairness.
For many bartenders, tips are a bonus and a vital part of their income. However, tipping standards have remained unchanged, hovering around 15-20% in most establishments. When I started bartending for establishments, a.k.a. strip clubs, I made $2.13 an hour. Typically, that check would cover state and federal taxes at payday, and sometimes, I would be left with a few cents to deposit. Tips were not just a part of my income. They were my income. A common misconception about service workers is that they are largely uneducated, lazy, and cannot or will not "get a real job." Just like any part of any industry, you do have people who fit that misconception, and that is why it sticks. However, in my experience, I would say that 95% of the people I have met and or worked with are some of the most resilient, hard-working, and educated people I know. For some parents, this job allows them to be present during the day. Some go to school, and this fits with their schedule. Some take care of a parent or partner, and while it is wildly unpredictable, the money can be significant. However, I go back to a key phrase, "wildly unpredictable, "because of most cases where gratuity is not mandatory and is at the patron's whim. In an era where the cost of living continues to rise, this outdated tipping rate no longer provides a livable wage for many service workers.
Why 30% Tipping Makes Sense
I remember when there was much controversy surrounding the proposal to increase the minimum wage. People were shocked that fast food workers could earn as much as $15 to $20 per hour. There were concerns about the impact on the economy and the value of education if these jobs paid as much as they did. The reality is that even with these proposed wages, it still would not be enough for a single person, let alone a family of four. I was asked to discuss a new law regarding handling tips during the pandemic. The law allowed employers to include non-tipped employees in a tip-pooling arrangement. This was intended for state minimum wage and regularly tipped employees. The concern was that combining tips this way could lead to unfair compensation, especially for those earning the tipped minimum wage of $2.13/hr. Despite all of this, raising the tipping minimum to 30% would be a fairer compensation model for the service industry, acknowledging the skills and efforts of bartenders and servers. Here is why a 30% tipping standard is both necessary and justified:
1. Increased Cost of Living: Inflation and rising living costs have significantly affected service workers. A 30% tip helps bridge the gap between their wages and a livable income.
2. Recognition of Skill and Effort: Bartending requires extensive knowledge of spirits, creativity in crafting cocktails, and the ability to provide exceptional customer service. A higher tipping standard recognizes this expertise.
3. Supporting Economic Equity: Many bartenders and servers come from marginalized communities and rely heavily on tips to support themselves and their families. By tipping more, patrons contribute to a more equitable economy.
4. Tab vs. Gratuity: While tipping is meant to reward good service, it often does not. The reality is that the tab you pay at the end of the night goes to the establishment, and the gratitude you choose to give is the service workers' compensation. This may seem obvious, but some actions and sentiments suggest otherwise. Essentially, the bar is outsourcing their compensation. Summary: Be a better patron and tip your service workers.
How You Can Make a Difference
Let us take a moment to appreciate the individuals who make our dining and drinking experiences memorable as we celebrate Labor Day. By adopting a 30% tipping standard, we can ensure that bartenders and servers are fairly compensated for their hard work and dedication. The next time you enjoy a well-crafted cocktail or a delightful dining experience, consider tipping 30%—a small change that makes a big difference.
Sources:
Bureau of Labor Statistics. "Occupational Employment and Wages, May 2024: Bartenders." [BLS.gov](https://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes353011.htm)
National Employment Law Project. "Why Tipped Workers Need Fair Pay." [NELP.org](https://www.nelp.org/publication/why-tipped-workers-need-fair-pay/)
Utah Labor Commission." Utah Labor Commission, 1 Jan. 2023, laborcommission.utah.gov
Comments